The Black hole Paradox
This paradox only exists because science can’t really totally let go of Gods.
It can’t help hanging onto words like inherent or intrinsic that have absolute beginnings or absolute ends.
When Hawking beautifully demonstrates that as far as energy is concerned, a black hole is not intrinsic, alarm bells rang out in the church of intrinsicicity.
They had for centuries contained Coulomb energy and for decades safely held black holes in a singularity, but agnostic Hawking put a goanna in the chook pen.
What to do?. Answer; Do what any priest would do. Extrapolate!.
Find something that absolutely cannot be proved as being not intrinsic or inherent;and before long some apostle came up with the idea that information is inherent, and it can be destroyed in black hole and become random. i.e. the intrinsic property called ‘order’ has an intrinsic end called ‘random.’
And simply because no one can ever prove that the random pages coming out of a black hole from a book that went in will ever reassemble in the future, the priests win and are back on their perches.
Moreover they have sidetracked us yet again from questioning why Coulomb Charges are intrinsic.(which they are not) All energy circulates.